Every new FPL season begins with chaos, optimism, and a spreadsheet full of players who suddenly look essential after one good Gameweek. But when you zoom out and analyse the top five performers from each Premier League club, patterns start to emerge — patterns that tell us who’s genuinely worth monitoring and who’s just a one‑week mirage.
Using the dataset from GW1 (25 August 2026), here’s a club‑by‑club breakdown of the early standouts, what their numbers actually mean, and how their upcoming fixtures shape their FPL potential.
Arsenal – Elite Output, Predictable Core
Arsenal’s top performers are exactly who you’d expect: Calafiori (9 points), Ødegaard (11), Saka (9), White (11), Tzolis (6). The headline is Calafiori — 41.2% selected, already the most-owned defender in the game. His blend of attacking involvement and clean sheet potential makes him feel like 2023‑era Gabriel with a higher ceiling.
Ødegaard and Saka remain the metronomes of Arsenal’s attack. Ødegaard’s 10.6 PPG is inflated by a single game, but the underlying involvement is real. Saka’s fixtures (AVL, CHE, SUN, BHA) are mixed, but he’s fixture‑proof.
Verdict: Arsenal’s top five are template‑defining. If you don’t own at least two, you’re playing FPL on hard mode.
Aston Villa – Midfield Depth Without a Clear Winner
Villa’s top performers include Hinshelwood (16), McGinn (1), Barkley (2), Buendía (2), Kamara (2) — a strange spread. Hinshelwood’s 16‑point haul is the outlier, and while his role is promising, Villa’s fixtures (ARS, HUL, NFO, TOT) are rough.
McGinn, Buendía, and Barkley all posted low returns but remain nailed. The issue is ceiling — Villa’s midfield is full of “good footballers, average FPL assets.”
Verdict: Hinshelwood is the only early standout, but sustainability is questionable.
Bournemouth – Quietly Efficient
Bournemouth’s top five: Armstrong (8), Evanilson (4), Kluivert (3), Rayan (2), Tavernier (10). Tavernier’s 10 points came from classic Tavernier chaos — set pieces, shots, and bonus magnetism. Everton, Newcastle, Brentford, Liverpool is a mixed run, but Bournemouth assets often thrive in awkward fixtures.
Evanilson looks lively and could become a mid‑priced gem if minutes stay high.
Verdict: Tavernier is the standout; Evanilson is the early bandwagon candidate.
Brentford – Midfield Value Everywhere
Brentford’s top performers: Ajer (8), Janelt (9), Lewis‑Potter (10), M.Sangaré (14), Wissa (4). Sangaré’s 14 points and 6.3 PPG jump off the page. His role is more advanced than last season, and Brentford’s fixtures (LEE, SUN, BOU, CHE) are favourable.
Lewis‑Potter continues to be a high‑energy, high‑involvement winger. Ajer’s 8 points are clean‑sheet driven, but Brentford’s defence is historically volatile.
Verdict: Sangaré is the real deal. Lewis‑Potter is a sneaky differential.
Brighton – Defensive Gold
Brighton’s top five: Hinshelwood (16), Boscagli (6), De Cuyper (17), Dunk (6), Wieffer (7). De Cuyper’s 17‑point haul is monstrous — attacking returns, bonus, and clean sheet. Brighton’s fixtures (CHE, LEE, COV, ARS) are tough, but their defenders are fixture‑proof when the system clicks.
Hinshelwood’s 16 points add to Brighton’s reputation for producing surprise midfield assets.
Verdict: De Cuyper is essential. Hinshelwood is a high‑risk, high‑reward pick.
Chelsea – Palmer and Pedro Carry the Load
Chelsea’s top five: Acheampong (3), Lacroix (6), João Pedro (11), Palmer (13), Rogers (8). Palmer’s 12.8 PPG is exactly what managers expected. He’s the most reliable Chelsea asset since Hazard. João Pedro’s 11 points show he’s still a bonus monster when he starts.
Rogers at 7.50M is interesting — his role is more attacking than preseason suggested.
Verdict: Palmer is essential. Pedro is a minutes‑risk but high‑ceiling.
Crystal Palace – Mateta the Only Real Threat
Top performers: Henderson (2), Kamada (3), Wharton (4), Richards (3), Mateta (2). Palace’s fixtures (MCI, FUL, IPS, LEE) are brutal. Mateta’s underlying numbers were decent, but returns didn’t follow.
Verdict: Avoid for now.
Everton – Midfield Surprises
Top five: Barry (8), Armstrong (8), Dewsbury‑Hall (11), Ndiaye (9), Pickford (7). Dewsbury‑Hall’s 11 points came from a more advanced role than expected. Ndiaye’s 16.1% ownership shows managers are already onto him.
Pickford remains a bonus machine.
Verdict: Dewsbury‑Hall and Ndiaye are legit mid‑priced options.
Fulham – Gonzalo & King Show Promise
Top performers: Castagne (6), J.Cuenca (3), Gonzalo (6), King (7), Palacios (2). Gonzalo’s 6 points and King’s 7 are encouraging, but Fulham’s fixtures (SUN, CRY, LIV, MUN) are rough.
Verdict: King is the standout; Gonzalo is watchlist only.
Hull City – Budget Defenders Everywhere
Top five: Mendy (15), Ajayi (14), Coyle (6), Egan (8), Tzolakis (10). Hull’s defence exploded in GW1. Mendy and Ajayi both hit double digits, and Tzolakis posted a clean sheet plus bonus.
Fixtures (COV, AVL, CHE, NEW) are mixed, but Hull defenders at 4.0–4.5M are gold.
Verdict: Mendy is the best 4.0 defender in the game.
Ipswich Town – Cheap Attackers With Upside
Top performers: Clarke (7), Emersonn (9), Enciso (5), Lukić (5), Núñez (4). Ipswich’s attack is lively, but fixtures (MUN, LIV, CRY, EVE) are tough.
Verdict: Emersonn is the standout budget forward.
Leeds – Solid Defence, Midfield Value
Top five: Bijol (10), Bogle (6), Justin (10), Stach (13), Trafford (9). Stach’s 13 points came from a box‑to‑box role with set‑piece involvement. Bijol and Justin look like bonus-friendly defenders.
Verdict: Stach is a top differential; Justin is a safe pick.
Liverpool – Midfield Explosion
Top performers: Gakpo (12), Gravenberch (5), Szoboszlai (8), Wirtz (2), Munoz (4). Gakpo’s 12 points and Szoboszlai’s 42.7% ownership show Liverpool’s midfield is the place to invest. Fixtures (NFO, IPS, FUL, BOU) are excellent.
Verdict: Gakpo is essential. Szoboszlai is a safe pick.
Man City – Defensive Dominance
Top five: Donnarumma (3), Guéhi (10), Gvardiol (9), Khusanov (2), Cherki (8). Guéhi’s 18.6% ownership and 10 points make him the standout. Cherki’s 8 points came from explosive involvement but minutes remain uncertain.
Verdict: Guéhi is the best City defender. Cherki is a punt.
Man Utd – Midfield Depth
Top performers: B.Fernandes (2), Andrey Santos (2), Cunha (2), Mbeumo (2), Tielemans (2). Low returns across the board, but fixtures (IPS, EVE, MCI, FUL) are mixed.
Verdict: Avoid for now.
Newcastle – Midfield & Attack Look Sharp
Top five: Botman (3), Elanga (9), Osula (4), Willock (6), Wissa (4). Elanga’s 9 points came from elite transitional play. Newcastle’s fixtures (TOT, BOU, LEE) are decent.
Verdict: Elanga is the standout.
Nott’m Forest – Midfield Rotation
Top performers: Aina (5), Murillo (4), N.Williams (2), McAtee (3), Ndoye (3). Forest’s fixtures (LIV, TOT, AVL) are awful.
Verdict: Avoid.
Spurs – Defence Outperforms Attack
Top five: Kinsky (2), Robertson (3), Senesi (3), Richarlison (2), Tel (2). Low returns, but fixtures (NEW, NFO, EVE) are decent.
Verdict: No standout yet.
Coventry City – Budget Gems
Top performers: Thomas (3), Tchaouna (2), Onyeka (2), Simms (2), Thomas‑Asante (2). Fixtures (HUL, MCI, BHA) are brutal.
Verdict: Avoid.
Final Thoughts
Across all 20 clubs, the early season picture is clear:
- Brighton, Brentford, Hull, Liverpool, Arsenal offer the strongest early assets.
- Hull’s defence is the biggest budget revelation.
- Sangaré, De Cuyper, Gakpo, Palmer are the early-season must-haves.
- Some clubs (Spurs, Forest, Palace) are immediate avoids.
brought to you by Co-pilot and JAM-IE
Share this content:
Leave a Reply